Question:
What dog should I get? Australian Shepherd or Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever?
2007-07-11 09:40:41 UTC
I just can't choose. I want a girl dog and I'd like her to be VERY afectionate, loving, and playful but not have exessive exercise requirements. The pros of the aussie is that it has nice wavy fur, and that it playful and so I heard very afectionate, but the con is that it might get bored at home sometimes, but it will be outside. The pros of the Toller is that is has a nice colour, and that they are almost always by your side, but the cons are that they are expansive because its not a popular breed, and they are need to much exercise, and they like hunting, which I don't. Here are two sites about them, http://animal.discovery.com/breedselector/dogprofile.do?id=1020 and http://animal.discovery.com/breedselector/dogprofile.do?id=2590 . Please help me decide. The aussie that I would be getting would look more like this though http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/88/Redmerleaussie02.jpg , or the puppy with blue eyes here http://www.dogbreedinfo.com/australianshepherdphotos3.htm
Twelve answers:
mspeep_14
2007-07-11 09:49:33 UTC
You should adopt instead, there are many animals that need homes and they are just as sweet as both of these breeds of dogs.
2007-07-11 09:47:29 UTC
How many times are you going to ask this question today? You have gotten enough answers. The bottom line here is no one is in your wallet or your situation, it is a decision that you must make on your own. To be honest with you, all you have talked about is looks, as if that is the most important thing in the world when it comes to a dog. There are a million other considerations, but, none have come up here, except of cource for looks. Make up your mind, no one here will.
?
2016-06-01 04:21:11 UTC
Many people love the idea of owning a dog but one thing that they have to keep in mind often times, is that the dog needs to be trained. While the pet may look heart-breakingly cute when it's in a shelter or at the pound, picking out the dog is only the first part of the relationship between dog owner and the animal. Many people don't understand that they have to put time and effort into socializing the dog.



An unsocialized dog will intimidate others, tear up the home, and will create an environment that can become so bad that the it will have to be returned. Many times when dogs have to be returned to shelters or to other resources, it will end up euthanized, which is very heartbreaking. All of this can be spared if a person learns the various techniques in order to socialize the dog.



One thing that they have to understand is that the he wants to be told what to do. It's in the canine nature to follow a leader. The dog will be more than willing to obey the leadership of its master. Here's a look at some common techniques that are used in dog training:



"Dog Whispering"



This is a technique that has been around for a while, but gained national notoriety over the last 10 years. Some people might hear this term and wonder how in the world whispering to a dog can train it! Whispering isn't meant to be taken literally in this case. As trainers have shown, whispering is a term that refers to connecting with a being or an entity on a very deep and almost spiritual level. When it comes to dog training techniques, dog whispering involves careful observation of the dog's behavior and actions.



It literally entails getting inside the mind and the behavior system of the canine. When a person uses dog whispering techniques, they interact with the dog on the canine level. Again, one the most common mistakes that people make is treating the dog like a small human being.



"Reward Training"



Reward training is very simple and it's one of the older tricks that works. This is a simple method of training the dog by positive reinforcement. Once he does what it is told to do, it receives a treat. How this works is that the dog owner must entice the dog towards the treat. Once the canine develops awareness for the treat, it develops a strong desire for it. When the desire for it is extremely strong, the dog owner pulls back. Then the dog receives a command and when the dog obeys the command, it receives the treat. The object is to make the dog associate a treat with the command.



"Clicker Training"



Other dog training techniques include one that is similar to reward training, which is called clicker training. How this works is that the clicker is incorporated to get the dog's attention. The clicker is clicked as a form of communication with the dog. It learns that there is a command or reward associated in conjunction with the clicker. Many people claim that this is fun, and they actually make a game with the dog by using the clicker for their dog training tasks.



"Ultrasonic Whistle"



Last, a relatively new form of dog training technique is called the ultrasonic whistle. This works because the ultrasonic sound is only heard by the dog. When the owner is trying to communicate a command, or stop the dog from barking, they will blow on their whistle when they want to communicate a command to the dog. The benefit of this is that the humans can't hear this noise, but the dog can hear it, and they will learn to associate the sound with a command.



Dog training techniques aren't hard to incorporate, but they are something that absolutely must be incorporated from the time a dog owner brings their new dog home. No matter how old or how young the dog is, they will need training. Once they are trained properly, they will be a wonderful addition to one's family.



Before You Spend MORE Money On Expensive Dog Trainers or Products,

Watch This Video First!



https://biturl.im/aU89v



Discover the powerful dog training secrets to eliminate over 30+ common behavioral dog and puppy issues with step-by-step instructions from one of the world's most skilled dog trainers!
2016-03-15 06:25:01 UTC
The Duck-Troller is a smaller but playful breed and is always excited to learn new thing and well play. The are trainable and love to help. These dogs are really hard to fine. This dog is eager to learn so training shouldn't be too difficult for you. They are affectionate and lovable. Australlian shepher are medium to large dogs and is even-tempered and well mannered towards strangers and friends. They are not difficult to train and are some what easy to an extent. They enjoy working, whether its learning new tricks, agility, ect. and they are highly energetic. They are both great dogs however if you really are an active person australlian shepherd are great as they demand lots of exercise while Nova exercise is'nt a lot but needed. Hope that helps
Cait
2007-07-12 10:27:01 UTC
Aussies and Tollers both have high energy, they both have long coats that need to be brushed every day, they both need training, exercise and stimulation so they dont go crazy and dig up your yard. Tollers are a rare breed in the US, so it might be hard to find, but to find a good Aussie breeder can be difficult too. Talk to breeders, tell them your situation, tell them why you want an Aussie, or why you want a Toller. It cant be all about looks, Aussies do come in a similar color to tollers (although it is a bit darker). But a nice looking dog doest mean it will be a nice dog for you to own.

Really the pros and cons for these breeds are about the same, pros are they are generally very affectionate, they love to be with their owners and please them, they are trainable, and have plenty of energy. Of course that can also be one of the cons, too much energy for some people, they can be a handful for inexperienced dog owners and they have A LOT of fur that needs brushing every day to prevent knots. Of course the toller is rare, and in turn expensive.

All i can suggest is to talk to breeders, they know so much about their individual breed and they are the only ones that can really help you in choosing the right dog for you.
Dog Rescuer
2007-07-11 09:57:15 UTC
We have had 2 Australian Shepherds...they have alot of energy and needs alot of exercise and DAILY fun stuff to do!!!!..Remember even when it's raining, snowing, etc you need to get her out and exercise them DAILY alot...A high energy dog Not exercised properly for their breed can go into a major depression and get ill., dig holes, chew stuff......Ive seen lots of people who have the wrong kind dog for their life style....Consider the sacrifice you will have to make for you dog also..and how big a yard you have , home etc...There are alot of good sites on line that will give your guidance on what kind of dog you would be best suited for....Good luck on your decision....Your daily life has EVERYTHING to do with what kind of doggy you need...A couch potato kitty sounds more like what you're looking for...

PS B oth the dog breeds you say you are deciding on would NOT be a good choice .....Because you have made it clear you DO NOT want a dog you need to put alot of exercise attention into...It may be that it's not time for you to have a dog yet.....Also if the dog is going to be left home all day while you're at work...We Always have had 2 when we were younger and worked so at least they could have company and not feel so alone...and the last thing the poor dog needs is to be put in a cage all day and when you get home you're too tired to want to do anything with them....Good luck with your research on Doggies...
ibbibud
2007-07-11 09:50:39 UTC
I don't know beans about the duck dog, but the Aussie will be beautiful and will want to play 24/7. She will be smarter than you but probably not give a dead squirrel about much other than her frisbie. I've had Aussies, being a popular horse people kind of dog. They are sheepherding dogs who know how to do their job and don't need much help from you once they know it..... it will not mind being outside, but how will it be out there? In a fenced yard or tied? One we had spent all its free time "patrolling" the grounds so there was this deep path going everywhere as it checked on all the creatures it needed to kill. There wasn't a rodent, bird or rabbit on the place when he was done, but he was sure happy! Very affectionate and eager to please if you can keep up with its energy levels.
Wolfen
2007-07-11 09:50:33 UTC
I owned an Australian Shepherd until she died. She was the best dog I could ask for. I got her when I was about 11 and she died about 10 years later. Everything that you listed is correct. She loved being outside and going with me when I rode horses or just went for walks. I don't know how she would have reacted to being kept inside for extended periods - probably about as much as I would like it.



The Australian is very dedicated to its owner. My father also had an Australian and the dog would stay by his side - never went with me as my dog did, but then my dog would not go with my father except around the yard. The dogs are protective of their territory - esp the males.



We now own a Sheltie and he is a very good dog that likes to be inside with us and go outside. I think the Sheltie is a better "city" dog than the Australian and is fairly intelligent.
ajg_hose
2007-07-11 09:49:55 UTC
my dog is a aussie shepherd mix and is very high energy... she would dig in the backyard if we left her back there. So there is a lot more training involved with an aussie shepherd.
LG
2007-07-11 09:47:56 UTC
I love both pups, but I like the retriever better
tonyar1976
2007-07-11 09:56:11 UTC
I would recommend the australian shepherd. I personally have a border collie, and was raised around working dogs. The aussies and border collies are very similar in temperment. I would make that you work with a good breeder who does the temperment testing on their pups. That test can show you alot of what their dominant adult traits could be. Our border tested straight mid-line, and is and awesome companion dog. We have a seven year old with cerebral palsey and he pays close attention to what she is up to without being too rowdy. He will normally feed off of my moods and energy level. If I am busy, he is good with being out and about, but if it is a lazy day, he is more than happy to lay at my feet and keep me company. I am actually looking at getting another dog, and right now a miniature aussie, is on the top of that list. They are overall great dogs, that will be a very loving companion, with alot of love and attention. With the aussie, they are smart, if you train them just a bit, they will take off and feed off of your normal habits. I hope this helps!!
rooster_nugget
2007-07-11 09:45:12 UTC
i like the duck retriever


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...