Question:
Why Should Dogs Tails "Not" Be Cut Off After Birth?
Sky Blue
2009-10-21 11:35:00 UTC
Do you consider this mutilation? Abuse? Puppies feel Pain when their tails are cut off and scream....Is this something we should all think twice about doing?

Any idea's on how to stop tail docking?
Ten answers:
AnimalManiac
2009-10-21 11:39:38 UTC
Unless he has a medical condition please don't touch his beautiful little tail.



Tail docking is the term given to the surgical removal of puppies’ tails for cosmetic purposes. The procedure was usually performed at 2-5 days of age; the tail is cut off using a pair of scissors or caused to drop off by occluding the blood supply using a tight rubber band. There are over 70 breeds of dog that traditionally have had their tails cut off a few days after birth. Many people think that dogs of docked breeds, which include Dobermans, Rottweilers, most terriers, spaniels, pointers and other gun dogs, are born with short tails – this is not true! The reason some breeds and not others are docked is simply because of the fashion set for that particular breed. Each breed has an arbitrary standard for where the tail should be cut off.



The RSPCA is opposed to the cosmetic tail docking of dogs because the procedure is unnecessary and compromises the welfare of dogs. In 2004, tail docking for non-therapeutic reasons was banned across Australia. Since then it has been illegal to dock dogs’ tails unless there is a medical reason behind the operation. Only qualified veterinarians are permitted to carry out the surgery, whereas before the ban tail docking could be carried out by anyone classified as an ‘experienced breeder.’ All previously docked breeds can now compete at dog shows with full tails, so there is absolutely no reason for any dog's tail to be docked unless they were born prior to 2004.



Tail docking is painful

Advocates of tail docking claim that it does not cause pain or discomfort, as the nervous system of puppies is not fully developed. This is not the case; the basic nervous system of a dog is fully developed at birth. Evidence indicates that puppies have similar, if not increased, sensitivity to pain as adult dogs. Docking a puppy's tail involves cutting through muscles, tendons, up to seven pairs of highly sensitive nerves and severing bone and cartilage connections. Tail docking is usually carried out without any anaesthesia. Puppies give repeated intense shrieking vocalisations the moment the tail is cut off and during stitching of the wound, indicating that they experience substantial pain. Inflammation and damage to the tissues also cause ongoing pain while the wound heals.



Pro-docking claims



The few remaining advocates of tail docking give a range of unconvincing explanations to defend their views. For instance, they say that some heavy coated breeds need to have their tails docked for hygiene reasons (even though many undocked breeds have thick coats and regular care is all that is necessary to maintain good hygiene). Another explanation is that docking prevents tail damage in hunting dogs. But most docked puppies are kept as family pets and are never used for hunting. And research has shown that docking does not reduce tail injury in the general dog population. Furthermore, many breeds of hunting dogs do not have docked tails, and the length of the tail in docked breeds varies according to the breed standard. The excuses put forward to support tail docking are plainly unfounded. There is simply no excuse for reviving this painful tradition.







Is it legal in other countries?



Cosmetic tail docking has also been banned in a number of countries including Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands, Finland, Germany and Denmark. Several other European countries including Cyprus, Greece, Luxembourg, Switzerland, and Austria have also ratified a European Convention that prohibits the cosmetic docking of tails. In the United Kingdom tail docking can only be carried out by a registered veterinary surgeon. The practice is opposed by the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons which describes it as an 'unacceptable mutilation'.







Why do some dogs still have docked tails?



You may still see adult dogs with docked tails, as the docking may have been performed before the ban was introduced. But you should never buy a puppy with a docked tail. If you get a dog from a breeder, make sure that they do not dock tails. If you suspect that tail docking is still taking place, please phone your state or territory RSPCA.



Other surgical modification of companion animals – ear cropping of dogs

Ear cropping involves the surgical removal of a portion of both of ears and is traditionally performed on specific breeds such as boxers, great danes, doberman pinschers or schnauzers. The practice was common in dogs bred for guarding, fighting, and hunting small animals and the historical reasons for ear cropping are similar to those for tail docking; owners said they wanted to reduce the incidence of ear injuries and make it harder for their dogs to be caught by the ears. Although few dogs are used for such purposes now, some bre
Catherine Rose
2009-10-21 12:05:34 UTC
Where do you live?

Tail docking is illegal in most parts of the world.

However, before it became illegal dogs for show were not disqualified for having undocked tails. Tails and no tails were both excepted.

Now, that there is the tail docking law, dogs with docked tails are disqualified in the show ring.



Personally, I am not a fan of the tail docking law and thing the ban should be removed. Whether the tail is 'docked' or not should be the breeders personal choice/decision.



As I am a mainly interest in the gun dog group, because I like a dog to have a job, it is annoying for me and others having the docking ban. Even though I do not show at the moment, I am considering showing possibly Weimaraners and/or German Shorthaired Pointers, both of which are normally docked for working purposes and do better without tails, it is either have a dog that can be worked only and have a docked tail, or have a tail show and work the dog, but risk the possibilityity of the dogs tail being damaged while working.
Lorraine
2009-10-21 11:42:21 UTC
It is now illegal in the UK -- but guess what --- it still goes on and nobody is policing it. Far too many other things to do.



Certain actual working breeds still allowed but not rotties, dobies, boxers etc. who only come within the working category.



Our kennel club is still registering illegaly docked litters - FACT. I have an email from them to say that they can only refuse registration if their is a prosecution ongoing.



I actually prefer my breed docked (rotties) but now their is a two tier system developing here and the good quality show dogs are not docked and the people that don't care are still docking. Most by the rubber band method.



We have even had a vet prosecuted here in the UK for still docking a litter.
anonymous
2009-10-21 11:41:39 UTC
*snorts*



Do you consider this mutilation? No



Abuse? No



Puppies feel Pain when their tails are cut off and scream Actually the feel little to NO pain as I have actually seen pups sleep through the procedure. They are fussing because they are being held and are away from the safety and warmth of their mother and litter mates.



Is this something we should all think twice about doing? Only if you are stupid enough to just let any so and so do it.



Any idea's on how to stop tail docking? Not a one. Don't like docking? Don't get docked breeds. Take your AR crap elsewhere please. I am sick and tired of people who DON'T understand the procedure and have no real knowledge on it trying to tell other people other ADULTS what they can and can't do with their property in a safe, humane and proper manner.



Lizzy: Bronchitis is a ***** lol.



To the OP: Show dogs are not the only ones docked. Working dogs are docked. Have you seen what happens to working dogs or even simply pets who have damaged those long whip like tails that should have been DOCKED? I have. I have also seen dewclaws hanging on by damn near nothing as their owners rush them in.



You say you've done it - did YOU do it or did a VET do it? I have no doubt someone doing a home job who doesn't know what they are doing or how to do it correctly will cause pain.
anonymous
2016-05-22 06:04:17 UTC
I think it might be for the look of the dog. Other people say that it is cus the dog is so strong. E.g. a boxer is very strong and gets excited easily- this means that its tail will be wagging really hard and probably will knock loads of things. Other than that i dont know, Lol!
anonymous
2009-10-21 11:40:43 UTC
Some working dogs need there tails docked have you ever seen a springer spaniel that has caught its tail in a barbed wire fence and its hanging off and then need to be removed



Be careful what you post when you don't know the facts!





A number of working gundog breeds have to hunt game through heavy vegetation and thick brambles, where their fast tail action can easily lead to torn and bleeding tails which are painful and extremely difficult to treat. Docking the end of the tail eliminates the risk of injury.



Working terriers are docked for the same reason. In addition, terriers which are bred to hunt below ground for purposes such as fox control, have their tails docked to a length which is more practical when working in a confined space.



Other non-working breeds which have an enthusiastic tail action, are also liable to damage their tails, even in the home.
anonymous
2009-10-21 11:46:18 UTC
THANK YOU RAYVEN!



Might as well allow it. If it is illegal people will resort to other UNSAFE methods...like DIY methods..rubber band, homemade surgery.



Keep it Legal, keep it safe.



I dont see how it compromises the "welfare" of the dog. Its like getting a babies ears peirced, or circumsizing a young boy. NO big deal.



Do you consider this mutilation? NO.

Abuse? NO. How is this abuse?

Puppies feel Pain when their tails are cut off and scream...?

UMM no Have you even witnessed a docking? I sure have. They sleep through the procedure.
?
2009-10-21 11:44:36 UTC
I think it's a needless procedure with nothing but cosmetic benefits. The risk, as with all surgical procedures, includes infection and death.



It is considered 'the standard' for many breeds and serious breeders of show dogs will continue to do it as long as the AKC permits it.



If you want to organize against tail docking -- and ear docking while you're at it -- start a web site and collect information from vets who oppose the procedures.
LizzyB
2009-10-21 11:52:06 UTC
Why don't you include dew claw removal and debarking while you are at the AR ranting. My dog, my property. So long as they are well treated and have proper vet care, why do you care? Hey Rayven!! Needed you here yesterday. Thumbs up.
gud ole kuntry boy
2009-10-21 11:42:10 UTC
I am against it. tail docking and ear cropping are the reasons we quit breeding min pins altho I love the breed. It is mutilation in my book.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...