Question:
My boyfriend and I want a german shepherd puppy..I have a few questions?
2011-03-02 20:19:59 UTC
I've been told a lot of negative things about german shepherds. Like they can snap at you randomly, unpredictable, human aggressive, not good with kids, scary, ate babies, etc.
I have a pitbull at my parents house, I am not swayed by the whole "scary breed" thing. Some of what people say is true though. My pitbull is a big, well behaved, baby. She licks and licks everyone and is the sweetest thing. shes never attacked another dog BUT she does get aggressive like shes ready to attack if she is on the leash in a city enviornment and sees another dog-especially if its another pitbull-oddly enough. anyways, i am asking this question because as people say pitbulls are "dog aggressive" i have seen this natural tendency in my pitbull, though shes never attacked. people say german shepherds are "human aggressive" and i am just wondering if this is a safe dog to have around children and just how much time for training is neccessary to train a GSD? ive never had one before and i do plan on having children. im only 18 so not for a while! but still. It will be my first dog to take care of 100% on my own (the pitbull was mostly mine but some shared responsibility with my parents).

What are some tips I should know and can you answer my questions I wrote about? thank you
Eight answers:
2011-03-06 07:22:37 UTC
Start with the breed's name - its real name translates as German Shepherd Dog - 3 words in the proper noun, so 3 capital initials needed, with GSD for short.



·· "they can snap at you randomly, unpredictable, human aggressive, not good with kids, scary, ate babies, etc."



Of course they can. So can Maltese, St.Bernards, etc etc. Invariably owned by lazy cretins, and the bitten are usually brats.

GSDs - indeed, all herding breeds - are THINKERS, and easily out-think drongos. So, to drongos and self-obsessed humans, herding breeds ARE unpredictable.



·· "I have a pitbull"



So why are you looking for another pooch? BTW, there's no such breed - there are several flavours of Bulldogs-crossed-with-Terriers around, one of which is the PBT, another the APBT. And the "Pit" part of the name is VERY significant.



··Q1: "i am just wondering if this is a safe dog to have around children"



When our son was born we had an 8 month and a 14 month GSD, both in training classes. The most danger Gordon was ever in was of being dropped when whoever was holding him received a damp nudge on the elbow, to point out "I'm here, and I'd like a fuss too, please."

When, as a toddler, Gordon sat on a litter of pups snoozing on the grass, it was me punished him, not the dam.

When he was old enough to have friends come over, the dogs were penned or brought inside so that they wouldn't mistake a noisy-boy game for "Gordon needs protecting."



Of course, my GSDs were very well bred with calm fearless character very important in the choice of parents & pup. And although my boyhood "Focker" got only the training I could think up (we lived WAY remote), and during his first year my first GSD got only what I could think up (we were an hour+ from the nearest training club, but we moved to the city after that and I became a class instructor), they were all definitely trained & loved.



··Q2: "just how much time for training is necessary to train a GSD?



The whole of its life.

My last pup came inside at 8½ weeks and had the run of the house 24/7. She was paper trained that afternoon (I know that pups "can't hold on" while I get my 8 hours of sleep). NO "accidents". Training her that my always-open bedroom is forbidden to dogs took a little longer - on 5 mornings I had to look in the passage for the aromatic sock she had been unable to resist stealing while I was boringly asleep.



··Q3: "What are some tips I should know"



Don't get ANY pooch until you:

• Have a door opening straight into a yard fenced to not only keep your pet home but to also keep stray dogs & stray brats OUT!

• Know the difference between real GSDs and the German Crouchers, NAmerican Ski-Slope Dogs, Prick-Eared Bassets, and Titanic Tail-Tuckers that your KC registers as GSDs: http://www.leabashiba.com/fashion.vs.GSD.htm

• Know enough to choose WELL. (That includes NOT getting another pooch of the same sex.)

• Have a plan for where Pup sleeps that does NOT involve a shut crate.

• Can bring it home at 7-to-9 weeks old and STAY HOME with it 24/7 for at least a week. (Partly to settle Pup in and convince it that the world is a fun safe place and you are the source of everything good in the universe. Mainly so you can OBSERVE 100% and LEARN its timing & signals for such as "Wanna go toilet" and "Wanna BITE something" so that you can PREDICT them and take instant appropriate action.

• Know that "socialisation" must be completed by 13 weeks old and has NOTHING to do with playing with strange dogs/people - it is about familiarisation & confidence-building.

• Can attend a proper training club's weekly classes for about a year, starting when Pup is 18 -22 weeks old.



◙ Add http://pets.groups.yahoo.com/group/The_GSD_Source to your browser's Bookmarks or Favorites so that you can easily look up such as rescue groups, feeding, vaccinations, worming, clubs, neutering, diseases, genetics.



◙ To ask about GSDs, join some of the 400+ YahooGroups dedicated to various aspects of living with them. Each group's Home page tells you which aspects they like to discuss, and how active they are. Unlike YA, they are set up so that you can have an ongoing discussion with follow-up questions for clarification. Most allow you to include photos in your messages.

Les P, owner of GSD_Friendly: http://pets.groups.yahoo.com/group/GSD_Friendly

"In GSDs" as of 1967
?
2011-03-03 04:34:34 UTC
-EDIT- SORRY I HAD TO EDIT IT ALL BECAUSE MY SENTENCES GOT ALL MESSED UP & IT DIDNT MAKE SENSE



We are Currently keeping my boyfriends german shepherd!

His tempermant has made us want to get a german shepherd when my boyfriend finds him a new house because his house burned down We are getting ONE! also my step dad has owned Many german shepherds.

From what i have heard from my step dad they are Great family dogs & since i have been keeping my boyfriends german shepherd i believe it! he listens great Even when he truely doesn't want to listen he still does.He is great with my little sister she is 11 & he has been around little kids before & acted great with babys and toddlers bc my boyfriends sister brought her kids around him & he loved it! he is a very well mannared dog i have ever seen my mom has been around german shepherds & the only mean one she met was also a white german shepherd that her dad owned & it tried to bite everyone! Also my REAL dads neighbors had a white german shepherd that was EVIL! but im not saying all white german shepherds are mean! i have just been told stories about them & seen my dads neighbors white german shepherd!My step dad has owned 5 & one white german shepherd which became mean too & he got rid of the dog & never got another white one!

i think you would he very happy with one they are very loyal dogs!

I think if you find a reptuable breeder the breeder can help you pick out a puppy that will suite you

& if you train it early you will have no problems! Its just a breed sterotype Don't Believe it they are great dogs!
SugarSugar
2011-03-03 04:30:09 UTC
Any dog can be aggressive, you need to train them for years of their life. German Shepherd is used for police dog and guard dog since the history of the breed, yes they can be aggressive if they are trained to, they can also be naturally protective.
2011-03-03 04:24:58 UTC
German Shepard's are good dogs despite what people say, as long as it gets trained it will be the sweetest dog in the world. They also make good guard dogs that are perfect for families and they are good with kids because I have had one his name was Jace and he was the best dog I have ever had.



If you have any more questions you can check out this site:

www.justdogbreeds.com



it has a lot of helpful information on every dog breed.
jb-mande
2011-03-03 04:26:45 UTC
Research the breed on Google...

I've known many german shepherds, none purebred though, and I haven't seen them be people aggressive.
?
2011-03-03 04:37:57 UTC
Depends on what bloodline they come from. The reason why they can be aggresive etc is because they used to be trained as gaurd and police dogs which is another way of saying "trained to attack strangers". They are very intelligent but they hate strangers and are bad with children
Monte
2011-03-03 13:36:46 UTC
I would not want to hav 1 around a newborn or toddler!
dimand_naz_lover_
2011-03-03 04:34:13 UTC
never ever ate kids if they are trained then thery are perfect dogs! big little angels!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...