Question:
Best & worst dogs for children. im confused.?
anonymous
2009-01-13 17:23:56 UTC
so today, i clicke don the internet and found a poor child was mauled to death by a pit bull... i decided dto do some research because i have a friend who has 2 young kids and she has a rare blue coated pit bull who seems very sweet but i was told he nips at the kids form time to time (like as a warning). I happend to watch the animal channel, and if i can remember the dog correctly, they said St. Bernards were one of the best, if not the best kind of dogs to have aroumnd children. So i did a little bit of research of "worst" dogs to have and "best" . i found the number one worst was pitbulls, rottweilers, german shepards and st. bernards chow chows and so on. I then went on the BEST kind of dogs to have.. and it said Golden Retreivers poodles and german shepards and so on and so fourth. I am kinbd of confused. So are st. bernards and german shepards good dogs or bad dogs to have for children? can anybody give me an accurate list? thanks.

oh and i will note: i understand every dog has the potential to harm sombody and be agressive. And i also understand the way you treat a dog also plays a role in how it will behave. I'm talking GENE wise. I'm talking in the genes that certain dogs have, according to their genes what dogs are okay to have around children, and what dogs are not. thanks.
Thirteen answers:
Kip's Mom
2009-01-13 17:31:37 UTC
Here is the most accurate list in the world:



1. Well bred

2. Well trained

3. Well handled



(and those apply to the children as well).



Breed is irrelevant.



And note - any "list" you find on-line will, at best, list only those breeds whose bites have been reported (and I'm sure there are a lot of dog bites, especially by small breeds, that go unreported), and at worst, will be complete fabrications.
?
2016-05-28 04:14:17 UTC
My screen name pretty well speaks for itself. I pretty much agree with everyone else's answers. You should NEVER yank your dog's collar or yell and NEVER HIT a dog, not saying you did. I got tears in my eyes when I read this because I lost my mother and my sister in a year and half, the last being my sister this past May, 2007. If it weren't for my babies, I have 3: a white Boxer, a Shepherd mix and a Pit Bull, all rescued dogs, I'd go nuts. When I cry, they're there for me to lick my tears. Let your boy do that for you. They do forget 5 minutes after they've made any kind of boo boo and their love is unconditional and they're so forgiving. Pet him and talk sweetly to him and I guarantee you'll get a wagging tail, unless he's timid and scared. Then you really have to prove to him you still love him. You're not a bad person. You just can't take your emotions out on him. He's not the cause of your problems. Our pets are like children with fur, they have a vocabulary of over 350 words and they're so smart. My pit bull is a little girl and she still has accidents in the house. I have never yelled at her once even though she watches as I clean it up. Just keep a can of carpet cleaner on hand and some old rags. Floors can be cleaned. Also, cages should only be used for potty training and when you're gone, not as a punishment. They'll relate that and think everytime they have to go in there that they've been bad. I know I'm talkative, but my love for animals is very strong. I'm a member of the ASPCA and when you think about the little guys that are abused, neglected and don't have homes, your perspective will change. Trust me on that.
BonBonMom
2009-01-13 17:45:37 UTC
I agree with other, whether a dog is good with children is primarily training and socializing. I live in a province that ban pitbull but my friend has a pitbull that is so well trained that will put any super dogs to shame. He used to be a therapy dog. When my friend said, go to bed, this dog will walk straight to his crate even you have a steak in front of him. I have a Newfie puppy, with all the great thing say about this breed, when my puppy was 4 mths old, he went thru a fear stage that basically he was afraid of little children. He will bark at them. Well, so I took him to a Christmas parade, he got touched by 100s children and totally fine with children now. It's all about socialization.



Really, it's not the breed it's about how much time you are ready to give.
Bumblebee
2009-01-13 17:38:57 UTC
American Pit Bull Terriers and Staffordshire Terriers ( the two original pit bull breeds used to be called Nanny dogs because of their good temperament with children. Most Pit Bulls who bite are half starved and isolated, even beaten Pit Bulls usually don't attack humans. Pit bulls are very human friendly and get along well with other dog's and animals if socialized well. They need a firm handler though and you would want to take another dog and your children to meet it before bringing one home to make sure the previous owners did their job raising it.



A second note on pit bull statistics is that the statistics come from newspaper articles and group 18 different 'pit bull like breeds' in the pit bull column which would obviously inflate the numbers.
anonymous
2009-01-13 17:36:24 UTC
There are so many things to consider:

How old are the children, there is a world of difference between a 5 year old and a 12 year old when you are selecting a dog as a family pet.

For example the Labrador is quoted as being a great family dog however an energetic pup/young dog can knock over a very young child with no fault on either side.

If you can see the temperament of the animals parents you can better judge how your pup will turn out regardless of breed.
JenniT
2009-01-13 17:51:37 UTC
ok...I have two children, 2 American Pit Bull Terriers, and a Miniature Pinscher....my children were toddlers when we got our pits as puppies, we have never had a problem, no nips....our min pin we got as a puppy and have had her about a year...I think she has nipped everyone in the house. All dogs are different...not just the breed but the individual dog. I have known several different people with children who had several different types of dogs...Rotts, Shepards, Pits, Labs, Cocker Spaniels...and the only one I have ever known to bite was the Cocker Spaniel. I have known two different families with two different Cocker Spaniels and had the same problems.
Kristine H
2009-01-13 17:43:36 UTC
Yeah, I'd stay away from dogs like boxers, pit bulls, and german shepards as they can be aggressive. You don't want that when children are around. Actually, when I was younger, I was bitten on the head by a boxer. The dog ripped my ear as well. I was rushed to the hospital. The dog almost killed me.



But for good dogs, I'd have to say labs. They are very gentle and tame. They do very well with smaller kids as well. They're just all around good dogs. There are other breeds of course that are good as well. I'm sure you've looked them up.
Rotten Rotts
2009-01-13 17:53:07 UTC
Kip's Mom said it best.

The dangerous dog list on the internet really piss me off.

My "dangerous" Rottweiler is a therapy dog that works with Autistic kid and Alzheimer patients.



DO your research as far as energy levels and what is best for you family. Do not condemn any breed, never leave children unsupervised with dogs, train, and socialize your dog and you will have a loving member of the family
Kaley
2009-01-13 17:32:01 UTC
german shepard are good dogs IF they get plenty of attention and exercise and discipline. German Shepards who are treated like people turn out aggressive. I haven't heard anything bad about St.Bernards yet.
Karen lvn
2009-01-13 17:29:12 UTC
Children and dogs should NEVER be left unsupervised regardless of what the breed is.
anonymous
2009-01-13 17:30:25 UTC
all dogs have their buttons. train your kids how to act around dogs and how to treat them
don't hate
2009-01-13 17:36:04 UTC
it's not the breed it's the way the animal is brought up.
Please Adopt and Save a life
2009-01-13 17:35:56 UTC
Generally the larger dogs are better with small children, small children really don't know the difference between a sof toy and a living small breed dog, and small breeds don't tolerate the roughness of young children, remember small breeds are incrediable fragile and can easily be dropped on the patio and killed or seriously injured.However toy/small breeds are quite suitable to older considerate children.



Top children dogs

Labrador

Temperament: This breed is highly intelligent, loyal, and deeply devoted. The Labrador Retriever is reliable, affectionate, and thrive on human companionship and attention. They are absolutely wonderful with children and get along exceedingly well with other dogs. They may be reserved with strangers and make good watchdogs. If this breed is left alone for extended periods of time without attention or stimulation they will become lonely, bored, and destructive.REQUIRE a minimum of 30mintues daily exercise-ideally twice a day, with a good run in a fenced in yard.



Golden Retriver

Temperament: Golden Retrievers are loveable, polite, and highly intelligent. They exude charm and confidence. They are sweet, eager to please, and devoted family companions. They do not do well if left alone for extended periods of time or they will become mischievous and destructive. They have a tendency to be overly exuberant and distractible. They are always gentle and patient with children. They are friendly with other pets. In fact, they are friendly with everyone. They tend to bark as a form of greeting. The Golden Retriever is not well suited for a two career family as they require an inordinate amount of human interaction and companionship.REQUIRE a minimum of 30mintues daily exercise-ideally twice a day, with a good run in a fenced in yard.



Collie

Temperament: The Collie has a very even and well-mannered temperament. This dog is regularly seen in homes with other animals and children, as they are very gentle and passive. Originally bred for herding, this dog has the tendency to nip at ankles as a pup, however most grow out of this stage. Willing to learn and very loyal, this dog will surely provide you with a lot of love.REQUIRE a minimum of 30mintues daily exercise-ideally twice a day, with a good run in a fenced in yard.



Newfoundland

Temperament: The Newfoundland is generous with love and affection. They are very sociable and friendly to visitors they know. They have a keen sense of responsibility and are excellent with children. They become so attached to their families that they cannot ever adapt to a new home or environment. They are generally good with other pets. This breed thrives on human companionship. They are gentle, heroic, and docile. Newfoundlands are extremely protective and will place themselves between their family and any danger that appears to be of a threatening nature.Yes they can and Will adapt to new homes-otherwise why would there be Newfie in shelters/pounds and rescues?REQUIRE a minimum of 30mintues daily exercise-ideally twice a day, with a good run in a fenced in yard.



Other dogs that are good with children

American Pitbull Terrier

Temperament: This breed is extremely loyal, deeply devoted, affectionate, intelligent, and good-natured. The American Pit Bull Terrier does best in a home with older considerate children. They will get along with other dogs they have been raised with but may exhibit aggression toward strange dogs and other small household pets. They are exceedingly protective of their family, home, and territory. American Pit Bull Terriers are not generally used for guarding due to their friendly nature. Aggressive behavior toward humans is an uncharacteristic trait in this breed. They are not recommended for the novice, apathetic, or sedentary owner.REQUIRE 4KM DAILY WALKS



American Staffordshire Terrier

Temperament: The American Staffordshire Terrier has a very even and stable temperament, which makes him a very reliable companion. This breed does do well around small children, but should not be left unsupervised around them, as this is a very powerful and rambunctious breed. The American Staffordshire Terrier can get along exceptionally well with other dogs, however the fighting strain of dogs should never be placed in a home with another dog as they still retain that aggressiveness. Proper research is necessary to be sure of the temperament of the dog.REQUIRE 4km daily



Staffordshire Bull Terrier

Temperament: Despite this breed's beginnings, the Staffordshire Bull Terrier is renowned today for their reliability as a companion and family pet. They thrive on human contact and are extremely loving, devoted, and loyal. This breed is dependable gentle and reliable with children, and for this reason were nicknamed the Nanny Dog. They are exceedingly protective of their family and make excellent guardians and watchdogs. They are not suited for homes with other dogs or household pets they have not been raised with. The Staffordshire Bull Terrier is not recommended for the novice dog owner.REQUIRE 4km daily walks



Boxer

Temperament: The Boxer is patient, dignified, and self-assured. They exhibit curiosity, but are wary of strangers. This breed is fearless and courageous if threatened. They are keenly alert and have a heightened sense of hearing, which make them excellent guard dogs. The Boxer adores children and other pets they have been raised with. They have an inordinate need for human companionship and do not like to be alone for extended periods of time. They are not well suited for a two career family. Insufficient attention may lead them into "bad" behavior in an attempt to be noticed.



St. Bernard

Temperament: The Saint Bernard has a somewhat sorrowful expression, but is actually very good-natured. They are excellent with children and other animals. They have a protective instinct for their family and make excellent watchdogs. They are sensible and loving and make a great family pet. They may display stubbornness, so owners must be very patient. They thrive on high amounts of love and attention. The Saint Bernard is prone to anxiety if left alone for extended periods of time and may destroy their owner's home and belongings.



Dogs that can be good with considerate older children

Pugs-Remember a child tend to poke and prode-and this can cause this breed to loose it eyesight-is a blind dog good with children?

Small children and pugs are not a good combination. While pugs are not generally aggressive dogs, young children tend to be fascinated with their curly tails and bulging eyes. Pugs eyes are very sensitive and easily injured, and having their tails pulled can make even the most easy-going pug snap at the person who is doing the pulling.



Bichon Frise

Bichon Frise puppies are NOT suited to small children, no matter how well-meaning the child. Children cannot help being clumsy, and that a child meant well is little solace to a Bichon Frise puppy who has been accidentally stepped on, sat on, rolled on, squeezed, or dropped onto the patio. Even Bichon Frise adults may feel overwhelmed by the loud voices and quick movements that children can't help making -- and stress and shyness (even defensive biting) may be the result.



Cavalier King Charles Spaniel

If you have small children, I do not recommend Cavalier King Charles Spaniel puppies, no matter how well-meaning the child. Small children cannot help being clumsy, and that a child meant well is little solace to a Cavalier puppy who has been accidentally stepped on, sat on, rolled on, squeezed, or dropped onto the patio. Even Cavalier adults may feel overwhelmed by the loud voices and quick movements that children can't help making -- and stress and shyness may be the result.



English Toy Spaniel

If you have small children, I do not recommend English Toy Spaniel puppies, no matter how well-meaning the child. Small children cannot help being clumsy, and that a child meant well is little solace to an English Toy Spaniel puppy who has been accidentally stepped on, sat on, rolled on, squeezed, or dropped onto the patio. Even ETS adults may feel overwhelmed by the loud voices and quick movements that children can't help making -- and stress and shyness may be the result.



Dachshund

If you have small children, I do not recommend a Dachshund. First, children cannot help being clumsy, and that a child meant well is little solace to a Dachshund puppy who has been accidentally stepped on, sat on, rolled on, squeezed, or dropped onto the patio. The Dachshund's long back is especially fragile and prone to damage when he is picked up incorrectly or dropped. Second, even Dachshund adults may feel overwhelmed by the loud voices and quick movements that children can't help making -- and stress and shyness may be the result. Finally, some Dachshunds simply do not tolerate any nonsense from children and will bite if pushed too far.



Chinese Crested

Chinese Crested puppies are NOT suited to children, no matter how well-meaning the child. Children cannot help being clumsy, and that a child meant well is little solace to a Chinese Crested puppy who has been accidentally stepped on, sat on, rolled on, squeezed, or dropped onto the patio. Even Chinese Crested adults may feel overwhelmed by the loud voices and quick movements that children can't help making -- and stress and shyness (even defensive biting) may be the result.



French Bulldog

Temperament: This hilarious little dog makes a wonderful playmate and is very affectionate. Alert and clingy, this breed does require lots of human attention to thrive. This is not a kennel breed and should always be kept in a family environment. Given proper socialization the French Bulldog can do well with other dogs, but should not be around small children, as they do not tolerate rough play.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...