Question:
what are some of the best guard dogs?
2007-10-10 09:27:28 UTC
im looking for a guard dog that is not too hard to train some that i was thinking of were doberman pinschers,german shepards,and pitbulls do you have any ideas?
21 answers:
2007-10-10 16:46:48 UTC
German shepherds, Dobermans, Bullmastiffs, Mastiffs, Neopolitan Mastiffs, Rottweilers, Boxers, American Bulldogs, Anatolian Shepherd Dogs, any kind of Belgian Shepherd, Pit Bulls, Cane Corsos, Airedale Terriers, Chow Chows, American Bullys, Australian Cattle dog, Australian Shepherd, Australian Kelpie, Dogo Argentino, American white Shepherds, Beauceron, Bovier des Flandres, Briard, Canaan Dog, Dogue de Bordeaux, Giant Schnauzer, Great Pyernees, Rhodesian Ridgeback, and Weimerarner.



Hope this Helps :)
2016-07-18 23:26:13 UTC
The issue is that dogs are poor generalizers - it's not that the dog is "sneaky, greedy" etc, but that they have no intrinsic sense of morality or "rightness" and so only think something is "bad" if it has bad consequences. If it has never had bad consequences except with a human in the room, then how on earth are they to know that the rules still apply with the human out of the room? You need to train in such a way that corrections and rewards occur when the dog does not think you are present - i.e. hiding around the corner. Read here https://tr.im/epOKw



I personally owned a Labrador Retriever (read: chow hound) that could be left 6" from a hot dog in a sit-stay for half an hour and not touch it - the word was "mine" and it meant that you don't touch that, even if I am not in the room, even if whatever, you DO NOT touch that. You could leave a plate of food on the floor for hours and not only would she not touch it, she would also keep the other animals (dogs and cats) from touching it.



In all probability, these dogs studied were just not properly trained/proofed before the experiment. With "proofing" to set them up and catch them in the act to give
2016-04-08 05:00:57 UTC
I think that you are referring to a personal protection dog. Guard dogs are bred specifically to guard property and belongings. Personal protection dogs are bred to protect not only property, but people as well. To answer your question, yes, a well-trained personal protection dog will protect its owner (with its life). People purchase personal protection dogs for safety/security reasons. Do you live in an area where homes are often burglarized? Do you live in a town where women are often beaten and/or raped? Do you have a stalker who will not leave your alone? Do you have children? Are you single women that lives alone? Do you dislike the idea of carrying around a handgun? Do you have a home or vehicle that you feel needs protection? If you answered yes to any of these, then you have a reason to purchase a personal protection dog. Edit: Regarding personal protection dogs and guns, personal protection dogs are specifically trained to target hands that are holding weapons. Advanced training can be done to teach dogs to attack when someone moves/motions their weapon hand (i.e.: a gunman raises his handgun to fire). Additionally, personal protection dogs are confronted with scenarios that could happen in real life (burglaries, car theft, etc.). They know when and how to attack. If a burglar went up again a personal protection dog, my bet would be on the personal protection dog. The burglar, like most people, would probably be startled by the dog. Therefore, he would not shoot right away. If he did go to shoot, the dog would most likely attack. Plus, even if the dog was hit, if it was not a lethal shot, the dog would still attack.
Really now
2007-10-10 16:42:10 UTC
I have two GSDs. They have always been protective, yet not overly so that you have to be concerned about them striking out at random. Mine are more of a "warning dog". They bark whenever someone comes up to the house, but have never come close to biting someone. Most people are bright enough not to challenge a large barking dog...they don't know if they bite or not. So I find my GSD are extremely effective and take training well. My female did jump through an open window with a screen on it when she was about a year old. This shady dude from down the way had stopped me in the yard to ask me a question. I heard a growl from the window, next thing I know she is jumping through the screen. Apparently, the dog didn't like his vibe. Thankfully the dog didn't hurt herself or the unwanted guest. Shady Dude never stopped to ask me anything else! We upped the dog's training time and never left the windows open that wide! It must have just been a puppy impulse, because she has never tried anything like that again! You'll never have a more faithful companion!
Nancy M
2007-10-10 15:53:41 UTC
There is a huge difference between a 'guard' dog and a personal protection dog. If you are that worried about your possessions, do as someone suggested and get alarms and guns and such but you can also have a dog that will be part of your family and can protect if necessary. For the most part that is individual and can occur in most any breed. Smaller breeds tend to be noisy and alarm type dogs but hardly a deterent. Larger dogs can be deterents simply by their existance in your household. Some of the suggested breeds can also be difficult to live with -- Malinois are primarily being bred at this time for sport training - some for police work - neither of these is suitable for personal protection as the drives needed for both of these endeavors can be very difficult to live with - although you can find individuals that are relatively easy to live with. A protection dog does little or no good out in the yard -- no one wants the stuff in your yard and if they do, heck, let them have it! So you need to select a dog that you want as a COMPANION - a dog you can live with and that is suitable for your lifestyle. Often dogs bred for the various protection oriented sports can be difficult to live with - again, they are often over the top in various drives and most of the general public is hard pressed to be able to handle normal drive dogs much less dogs that will go through fire to bite someone and is always 'on'. Basically select a breed you like - that would suit your situation - learn about it and see if it is still something you would like (I personally had difficulty with GSDs as they are not thinking dogs to a great degree and I like a dog that can do quite a bit of abstract thinking and I couldn't stand the coat!) - then locate a good, responsible, knowledgeable breeder and see about getting a dog that is confident, stable and that you can live with the energy level of -- then just love it -- do some obedience training with it and protect it -- it will reciprocate if the need arises -- that doesn't mean ANY dog will protect you - again, confident and stable temperament with the capability to bond strongly with you and your family - dog oriented dogs won't do this - over the top sport dogs won't do this - fear bitters won't do this... in the mean time select other methods of protection and don't put your family or your dog in a situation or place where this is necessary.



If you want a 'guard' dog, as in a dog that you put out in the junk yard and make it mean enough to bite anything that wanders in the area, then by all means, don't get a dog -- get a life.
Old Cop Dog
2007-10-10 09:49:00 UTC
You only have to look to the Police Departments to see what a good guard dog is. Mots have German Shepherds, but in recent times they are going to the Malenwa. Their more of an aggressive dog because of their drive.



This can be a long answer, As you see by the others. I'll try to make a simple chose list.



Make sure your not going to have problems with liability insurance



Check to see what Stat and Local laws regulate Guard/Protection dogs



Take inconsideration if your young, you may want to have children in the future. What effect will that have.



If you own a home, how is your neighbors going to feel about having a guard dog next to them



You have to answer these before considering get a dog to protect. Now the type of breed should be one that is recognized as a family dog as well as a good protector. That was one of the main reasons for the Police Dept. going for G.Sheps.



But make sure you and the dog can live together. Get one that you know bonds well with their owners.



I personally recommend a Shepherd. they have that Rin TinTin recognition
2007-10-10 09:42:37 UTC
Guard dog training should be left to the professional dog trainers. It is a very difficult regimen to learn and has many prerequisites such as basic obedience and socialization. Many people have tried to obtain & train a guard dog with no education or professional assistance and it most often leads to disasterous results. Please don't further the demise of the "bully dogs" by trying to train one to attack. If you really want a good guard dog, then purchase from a reputable breeder, seek professional training for yourself and the dog and start it around 12 weeks! My choice would be an APBT or GSD. Sometimes just the presence of these dogs in a yard is a deterrent to theives.
Rick Ven
2007-10-10 10:31:05 UTC
It depends on what exactly you mean by gaurd dog. As others said any dog can and will be a guard dog. However, if you are looking for breeds notoriously used as guard dogs, the list is very long. Giant Schnauzer, Bouvier, Boxer, German Sheppard, Akita, Mastiffs, Great Dane, Dobies, pretty much anything with bulldog or mastiff in it, etc., etc.
beenthinkin'
2007-10-10 09:37:59 UTC
ANY dog can be a good guard dog. I have a Border Collie who is extremely protective and a German Shepard who barks when someone is here but wouldn't hurt a fly but then there's my Pomeranian and she's the one who guards us. She isn't afraid of anything! No matter what dog you choose as long as you are good to them they will love you and automatically protect you and guard their home. The dogs you listed are all great dogs but your choosing them on reputation not on ability. Out of all my dogs - the easiest to train was my border collie. It's built in them to learn and work. They're the smartest dog breed in the world. Any dog you choose will want to please you - even a chiwauawa.
DP
2007-10-10 09:36:52 UTC
Don't get a Doberman for a guard dog. If you truly have something worth protecting, then get a security system / camera installed. Dogs are companions, for you to take care of. Dogs are not meant to guard your .. possessions.



That's cute that people think that.. If all dogs will protect their home / family if they need to.. what happened here??



Dogs drowned during attempted burglary

Margate, FL (US)



Police are searching for a burglar who they say silenced two dogs by drowning them in a home's pool before he tried but failed to break into that house.



http://www.pet-abuse.com/cases/12388/FL/US/





How did this man drowned 2 dogs?? Weren't they protecting the home??



Perhaps your family pets, will not be able to protect you if the right person wants to get into your house. You should not rely on a dog to save your life.....

If the dog is not trained, you cannot even begin to assume that the dog will save you.
Erikka
2007-10-10 09:33:27 UTC
Pitbulls aren't a breed... There called American Pitbull Terriers or Stafford bull terriers.

But why would you want a guard dog? there the ones that bite people the most and then you'll have a huge lawsuit. Dogs are pets not guards, if you want a guard hire a body guard.
zooworld101
2007-10-10 09:34:08 UTC
With the right kind of training, any dog can be a good guard dog. I doubt breed has anything to do with a dog's ability to be a guard dog. But honestly, I think dogs should not be guard dogs. They're best as family pets, not guard dogs.
rich
2007-10-10 09:41:54 UTC
I have 2 pittbulls and they are very protective of the house, me and my girlfriend and they are very easy to train and their not mean and unapproachable despite their rep, but they do have a king sense of suspicious behavior in people. I was walking them last night and a guy who looked suspicious to me was walking behind us kind of weird didn't look like he was headed anywhere special, and my dogs were barking at him. I could tell that he made them uneasy and they were trying to scare him off, because they don't usually just bark at people while we're walking. Even strangers.
squizzys mum
2007-10-10 09:48:28 UTC
my grandfather had poodle that was very protective of him.she would bight if you made a sudden move towards him.After she died he got a chihuahua and he was exactly the same.If you treat a dog well it will give its life for you no matter how big or what breed it is.
Wicked Wanda
2007-10-10 09:36:59 UTC
For a breed that was adapted to the role of the guard dog, the Giant Schnauzer has succeeded remarkably. While not as popular in the United States as some other breeds, the rest of the world knows and respects this breed as a premier police and military dog. Many European countries actually prefer the Giant to all other such breeds since these dogs have distinguished themselves as first-rate guard/protection dogs.



Due to their selective breeding as protection dogs, Doberman Pinchers possess a strong natural instinct to protect their pack members and territory. The Doberman will alarm his master of any suspicious activity on his territory as any good watchdog will do, but he will also display willingness to take matters in his own hands - teeth is a better word - and his eagerness to do so is generally unrivaled among his working dog counterparts. Dobermans are ofthen the choice of guard and Schutzhund trainers for attack training. As a protection dog, a stable Doberman is an excellent choice, when he receives leadership and proper exercise. But this breed is not for everyone.



Strong protective instincts. As police dogs, they excel in many areas of law enforcement, including drug detection, tracking, cadaver search, and apprehending suspects. Puppies need pack training and obedience training can begin as early as three months. When a Rottweiler become s a pack leader, the consequences can be tragic for his owners: they are invariably at the top of the list of dog breeds involved in dog bite fatalities.



For centuries, Mastiffs have been used as sentry dogs in Europe. Because of there massive size, they are excellent deterrents to trespassers. Most guard dogs first warn there victims with noise, but Mastiffs work silently. They will knock intruders to the ground with force and weight (a two-hundred pound Mastiff is not uncommon.)



As protection dogs, quality German Shepherds are regarded highly. Their alertness, loyalty, combined with high intelligence, and a love of children make them a superb choice. According to one of the most famous guard dog trainers, Captain Haggerty, "This is the best all-around guard dog."



The Belgian Malinois is greatly renowned for his exceptional ability as an all-purpose working dog. He is highly appreciated as a police and service dog and has proven his utility as a guide dog for the blind, and as a Red Cross, customs, border patrol, avalanche, disaster and rescue dog. He ranks high in protection work and enjoys the reputation of being a hard-biting Schutzhund dog.



As a family protection dog, Boxer ranks high. This is a breed that possesses an extraordinary ability of discriminating when it comes to reading the character of people.



Great Dane is an impressive guard dog if he simply stands still and barks. It is as a deterrent that the Great Dane does his best work as a guard dog. Some do reasonably well in guard dog training. They just don't seem to relish such work the way Dobermans, Rottweilers, German Shepherds and other working dog breeds do.



Rhodesian Ridgebacks are tough, but not vicious. Loyal and exceedingly protective of their human families, these large hounds do an excellent job as guard dogs.



Resembling more the Bullmastiff than the Bulldog of English origin, the American Bulldog is a strong dog that is often used in weight pulling eventys. This breed is fast gaining popularity as a family protection dog.



Traditionally used for dog fighting and known for his territorial and determined nature, the Presa Canario is a powerful deterrent that can react with great speed in a crisis situation. The Presa possesses a steady disposition, though he distrusts strangers. He has a deep, chilling bark well suited to warning suspicious strangers of his intentions and abilities.



Steady, resolute and fearless, the Bouvier des Flandres is an all-around service, police, and guard dog and also an outstanding family companion. He has an innate propensity to protect and guard his human family and territory. He differs from other working breeds in his serene, calm and thoughtful nature. Because of his laid-back disposition, he is more amenable to control than many other working breeds. Some individuals can be stubborn and aggressive, so he needs strong leadership from his owner.



The Beauceron is gaining recognition around the world as competent guard dog and protector. He has a most keen sense of smell and during the World War II he was used as mine detection dog and on the front lines to run messages as he was undeterred by exploding bombs or military fire. They were also used to pick up trails, detect mines, find the wounded and carry food and ammunition to the front lines. Highly trainable and always willing to work, Beaucerons are used by the French police and Army in apprehension of criminals (tracking and bite work), personal protection, narcotics detection, riot control, search and rescue, body recovery, prison security and secured escort.



Although the breeds above are the ones used and bred for protection purposes, any dog can be a guard dog.
Smile like you mean it!
2007-10-10 09:33:42 UTC
An Alsatian Or German shepeard
2007-10-10 09:44:51 UTC
I have a rat terrier that is ready to tear something up!!! No one nor my dogs can come ear me without her going on a rampage.
rjn529
2007-10-10 09:30:52 UTC
Any dog will protect it's people and property, breed does not make a difference.
2007-10-10 09:39:10 UTC
i have a jack russell and he protects me and my kids when we are in the house! if someone comes in our house that he dont know then he will growl and bark and constantly keep his eye on them! and if i tell him NO then he will stop and lay down.but if i told him to "get it" then he would bite.
2007-10-10 09:33:05 UTC
GSDs are the fastest learners when it comes to shooting a pistol. Very helpful for guarding.
¸.•*´`*♥ AyYıldız ♥*`´*•.¸
2007-10-10 09:35:26 UTC
GERMAN SHEPHERDS definatly..mine is still just a puppy but he is soooooooo protective


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...